A nostalgic classic with a bakery twist! Our Fluffernutter Cookie Sandwich takes two soft, rich peanut butter cookies and fills them with a cloud-like swirl of peanut butter and marshmallow fluff buttercream. It’s the perfect balance of salty and sweet, creamy and chewy. Every bite melts in your mouth and brings all the nostalgic vibes—only better, because it’s made from scratch with bakery love. Whether you’re treating yourself or sharing, this cookie sandwich is pure comfort in dessert!
FLUFFERNUTTERS
$25.00
per dozen
per dozen
Our Fluffernutter Cookie Sandwich takes two soft, rich peanut butter cookies and fills them with a cloud-like swirl of peanut butter and marshmallow fluff buttercream. It’s the perfect balance of salty and sweet, creamy and chewy—bringing back all the flavors you loved as a kid, only better.
Each bite melts in your mouth and delivers a warm hug of comfort and joy. Made entirely from scratch with real ingredients and a whole lot of Crumb Believable love, this cookie sandwich doesn’t just satisfy your sweet tooth—it creates a full-on dessert moment. Whether you’re treating yourself, gifting a friend, or (attempting to) share, the Fluffernutter is pure nostalgic indulgence… no spoon or crust-cutting required.
Ingredients List
Pay Your Way
Important: You must add your Order # in the "Notes" section. Payment must be sent before order is fulfilled.
Instagram 
Facebook 